10 Advantages and Disadvantages of Reddit vs Quora: What You Need to Know

3
By: | May 4, 2021 | Tags: ,
Reddit vs Quora

Reddit vs Quora: Which is the better social media site?

If you only had time to use one social media site (and many of us do), and your choices were Reddit vs Quora, which information-sharing site should you choose?

By the time you are done reading this article on Reddit vs Quora, you will have descriptions of each website, explanations of how they work, the similarities and differences of both Reddit vs Quora, and a review offering my opinion of the advantages and disadvantages of each site.

This guide to Reddit vs Quora will examine 3 advantages of Reddit, 3 advantages of Quora, 2 disadvantages of Reddit, 2 disadvantages of Quora, 12 similarities, and 4 differences.

In other words, this article shares 26 important things you need to know about Reddit vs Quora.

Let’s dive in and assess Reddit vs Quora to determine the advantages, disadvantages, similarities, and differences of the two websites to determine which social media platform is better for you.

Reddit vs Quora: What are the Similarities?

There are many sites like Quora, and Reddit is one of them.

What do Reddit and Quora have in common?

  • Both Reddit and Quora are information-sharing sites.
  • Both Reddit and Quora are popular websites.
  • Both Reddit and Quora are social media sites.
  • Both Reddit and Quora have content-based communities.
  • Both Reddit and Quora provide branding opportunities.
  • Both Reddit and Quora provide the potential for traffic generation.
  • Both Reddit and Quora have an upvote system that results in a boost in visibility for the content creator.
  • Both Reddit and Quora frown on self-promotion.
  • Both Reddit and Quora have recognition systems in addition to upvotes.
  • Both Reddit and Quora allow people to follow you.
  • Both Reddit and Quora have mobile apps.
  • Both Reddit and Quora are free to use.

Reddit vs Quora: What are the Differences?

Reddit

History of Reddit

Reddit was founded in 2005. By 2012, Reddit reached two billion page views a month (Source).

Reddit was named “Reddit” since the founders wanted people to be able to say, “I read it on Reddit.”

Reddit is called the “Front Page of the Internet” since so much information can be found on Reddit.

How Reddit Works

Redditors, as Reddit users are called, post links, photos, or videos.

In addition to being a discussion forum, Reddit is also known as a news aggregator.

The information you find on Reddit is divided into communities called subreddits. You will find subreddits on any topic imaginable.

It’s true: Recently, I saw a subreddit devoted to chicken nuggets. There are actually over 2.2 million subreddits on Reddit.

Some of the “mature, NSFW” subreddits don’t allow people in unless they are over 18 years of age.

In subreddits, people ask and answer questions, share frustrations or joys about a topic, and discuss the topic. Reddit’s subreddits are discussion forums organized around content niches. Some Reddit subreddits are AMA, (Ask Me Anything), but those are in a minority.

Some of the subreddits have moderation and some don’t.

When you check out a subreddit, you’ll see metrics like how old the subreddit is, how many members are in the subreddit, and how many members are currently active.

These metrics are important. You want to join an active subreddit. If one doesn’t work out, try another until you find a fit. Some of the hottest subreddits like the WallStreetBets subreddit (that recently made the news due to stock manipulation) have over nine million members.

Members can upvote each other’s content, downvote, or not vote at all.

You can use Reddit coins to buy awards for commenters that include Reactions, Medals, Premium Awards, and Animals.

Disadvantages of Reddit

Reddit is confusing.

Rules vary.

For instance, subreddits have different rules.

First, some subreddits allow self-promotion, and other’s don’t.

Next, you need to label your content with a Flair. The Flair states what type of content you are posting. In other words, you need to state if you are posting a discussion starter, a question, or a poll, etc.

When I first started at Reddit years ago, I thought I’d get lots of karma. The karma seems to have little effect when you use Reddit as it is supposed to be used, as a discussion forum.

Knowledge of Terminology is Needed

Top 10 terms you need to know to be successful on Reddit include:

  • comment karma
  • post karma
  • subreddit
  • upvotes
  • downvotes
  • flair
  • AMA (Ask Me Anything)
  • OP (Original Poster)
  • Reddit coins
  • Awards

Related Reading: 119+ Blogging Terms You Need to Know to Be a Better Blogger

Reddit Has a Toxic Vibe

Users criticize you with comments

People are quick to slam you if they don’t like what you’ve written.

I once posted information that was sort of a mini blog post. I thought I’d use the content to brand myself as someone knowledgeable in my niche.

Instead of being impressed, someone in the Just Start subreddit called for five moderators to remove my content which I ultimately removed myself.

I politely asked the woman what I did wrong. She responded I’d broken a rule. When I reviewed the rules, I couldn’t figure out which rule I’d broken.

It’s true: The vibe at Reddit is so snarky, there is even a subreddit devoted to being snarky! It’s called “Blogsnark.”

Users criticize you with downvotes

On another occasion, someone asked for a recommendation for an SEO course. My Blogging Academy has SEO courses, so I recommended mine. Five people downvoted me.

On Reddit, unless the members of the subreddit know you, promotion is seen as spamming.

Quora

History of Quora

Quora was founded in 2009 and became available to the public in 2010. One of the founders, Adam D’Angelo, originally worked for Facebook but left to create Quora, a question-and-answer site.

Quora is called “Quora” since the name comes from the word “Quorum” which means “to come to a consensus” or “come to an agreement.”

Quora users are called “Quorans.”

How Quora Works

Like on Reddit, you will find a great deal of information on Quora since Quora is a Question and Answer site.

People go to Quora primarily for two reasons, to get information and to offer information.

When you offer information and answer questions on Quora, you cite your credentials and experience that make you knowledgeable about topics.

When you go to get information, you type your question, and the site recommends people who would be knowledgeable to answer your questions based on their stated credentials.

In addition to being able to network one-on-one, you can participate in a content-based community.

If you want to try to monetize, Quora has a Partner Program.

Differences Between Quora and Reddit

Community Names

Reddit’s communities are called “subreddits” while Quora’s communities are called “Spaces.”

Purpose

People go to Quora as opposed to Reddit since on Quora, they get one-on-one help finding information to answer their questions.

Moderation

Quora is heavily moderated while not all subreddits are moderated.

Links

Bloggers are discouraged from leaving links at Reddit. In contrast, bloggers can leave links at Quora if the links are to supplemental information.

Disadvantages of Quora

Quora is Confusing

Sometimes, I get notified that my answer was sent to a large number of people. However, that doesn’t seem to result in any kind of a traffic boost or have any benefit at all.

Also, no one seems to know the minimum length of an answer. How long does it have to be to prevent the answer from getting collapsed? No one I know has that answer.

Quora gives recognition like “Top Writer.” What are the effects?

When it comes to Reddit vs Quora, clearly, both sites are confusing.

Quora has a Toxic Vibe

I find people accused of spamming who are genuinely trying to help users and not spam at all. When they get accused, their answers are collapsed and no one can see them.

When people try to appeal their ban, the result is usually a deaf ear. The powers that be may write back that they stand by their decision. That’s if you are lucky to hear back at all.

The staff at Quora accused me of plagiarism and collapsed my answer. I copied an excerpt from my own post. When I appealed I was copying my own writing, the staff never responded. My answer remains collapsed.

Next, have you ever been “flamed” by someone at Quora? I have. One of the critical commenters even admitted to “flaming” me. Note: Flaming means “posting insults online.”

Most of the time, people appreciate my answers. However, a few times people don’t agree with my answers and seem mad.

For instance, if someone asks my opinion of a social media site and expects me to bash a site I praise, the user responds angrily.

For the reasons stated, when it comes to Reddit vs Quora, both sites have toxicity.

Advantages of Reddit

Considering all the disadvantages of Reddit vs Quora, are there any advantages to using these social media platforms?

Absolutely!

What are the advantages of using Reddit?

  • Information Sharing
  • Branding
  • Traffic Generation

Information Sharing

As mentioned, Reddit is called “the Front Page of the Internet.”

According to Oberlo’s 2020 data, Reddit has over 2.2 million subreddits. Now, that’s a lot of information!

Note: When you go into a subreddit, check to see the recency of the information. If the community isn’t active, the last post could be weeks or even years old.

Reddit vs Quora

Look at the screenshot.

Under the name of the subreddit are the metrics you need to know to decide how active the subreddit is.

This particular subreddit, r/blogging, has 82,940 members. At the time I took the screenshot, 100 were online. These metrics show r/blogging is an active subreddit.

Branding

As social media marketers know, marketing on Reddit is difficult. Why? Redditors don’t know who you are and don’t want to give their money to strangers.

The best strategy you can use in hopes of ultimately making sales is to brand yourself as an expert in your niche on Reddit.

There are plenty of opportunities for this. You can show your knowledge by responding to a Redditor’s question or responding to the person’s comment. Add more information to the discussion. You’ll brand yourself as a knowledgeable source.

You can also brand yourself as an expert by creating a new post. Do not link to your content or products in this post. You want to look knowledgeable not salesy. If you do end up looking salesy, people will label you a spammer and downvote your content which will have the opposite effect.

Traffic Generation

I just wrote that Redditors don’t like marketers. This includes content marketers. Therefore, the question begs: Is it possible to generate traffic on Reddit?

Sure!

If you follow the branding tips, people might be interested in checking out your website.

Look:

Reddit vs Quora

On December 30, I received 49 pageviews from Reddit to my site, and that’s when traffic is normally slow around the holidays.

Reddit is in my Top 10 social media referrers coming in at Number 7.

Follow this strategy so you can generate traffic without looking like a spammer and getting downvoted:

Offer your link to people who sound interested.

For instance, I am a member of the Facebook subreddit where people complain they are in Facebook Jail. I tell them I wrote an article explaining how to get out of Facebook Jail, and if they would like, I will return to the subreddit with the link. People generally say yes.

I even sold a blogging course this way. Someone asked for a link to an SEO course. I explained I have many SEO courses in my Blogging Academy, and I’d return with the link if he would like. He requested the link, and I made a sale!

Advantages of Quora

What are the advantages of Quora?

  • Information Sharing
  • Branding
  • Traffic Generation

Information Sharing

Like on Reddit, you can ask or answer questions on Quora.

Branding

Reddit vs Quora

I use this honor for branding. Being a Most Viewed Writer on Quora is a feather in my cap.

Traffic Generation

Look:

Quora lets you know when your post is sent out in the Quora newsletter. As you see in the screenshot, Quora also informs you as to how many people viewed your content.

Obviously, not all these people click your link. How much traffic can you generate from Quora?

Look once more:

As you can see from this Google Analytics screenshot, Quora accounts for half of all my social media traffic.

Reddit vs Quora: Frequently Asked Questions

Is Quora a copy of Reddit?

Not at all. Quora is a question-and-answer site while Reddit is a discussion forum and news aggregator.

Which is better, Quora or Reddit?

That depends on your needs. If you need a discussion forum, Reddit is the platform for you. If you want one-on-one help answering a question, go to Quora.

Wrapping Up: Reddit vs Quora

In closing, this post shared 12 similarities that Reddit and Quora share, 2 disadvantages of each site, and 10 terms you need to know to use Reddit.

In addition to sharing similarities and differences, the post shared the advantages and disadvantages of using Reddit vs Quora.

Since both sites have 12 of the same similarities, and they both have the same 2 disadvantages when it comes to Reddit vs Quora, how will you decide which platform to use?

Which is better: Reddit vs Quora? They have different benefits. When you want to discuss, go to Reddit. When you want to get a question answered, go to Quora. The answer to the question, “Which site is better?” is “Which site is better for you?”

Readers, please share so social media users know the differences between Reddit and Quora.

I look forward to your views in the comments section. When it comes to a comparison of Reddit vs Quora, can you suggest similarities and differences not mentioned in this post?

  1. Johnson Michael

    Thank you sharing this. According to me Quora is more focused towards problem solving and reddit is more like platform for discussion. And I’m using both of them.

    • Janice Wald

      Hi,
      You have made an accurate distinction between the two platforms. It was my pleasure to share. Thank you for commenting and adding to the discussion.
      Janice

  2. sweety kumari

    Hey Janice ,
    Your post is very informative and useful.
    You have mention the awesome pro and cons of reddit and quora which is very informative.I have uses much which i very helpful for everyone but you have also mention the its pro and cons which is nice to use.

    thank you
    -sweety

Would you like to share your thoughts?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

LinkedIn
Share
Instagram
%d bloggers like this: